Your trusted platform to guide you to legitimate online courses that delivers real results.
Practical Etsy training for building a real online business with clear, actionable steps, though lacking advanced strategies
We spent considerable time analyzing Nancy Badillo's Etsy Mastery Course, and here's what we discovered. This self-paced program promises to guide sellers through launching, managing, and scaling profitable Etsy shops. Nancy, who's been in digital marketing since 2009 and claims to have helped over 12,000 students (we couldn't independently verify this number), structures the course around her personal experience of generating $21K in her first year on Etsy.
The course contains over 100 video lessons spread across 7+ core modules, covering everything from initial shop setup to advanced topics like Etsy SEO and scaling strategies. What caught our attention was the comprehensive approach, starting with market research and niche selection, then progressing through product photography, listing optimization, and marketing tactics.
Students receive downloadable resources including email templates, planning sheets, and checklists. The program also includes access to a private Facebook community where Nancy reportedly provides feedback (though we noted this isn't guaranteed one-on-one support unless you purchase her coaching upsell).
For $297, you're essentially getting a structured roadmap that could save weeks of piecing together free YouTube videos. However, we found that experienced sellers might find the content somewhat basic, as much of the foundational material is available through Etsy's own Seller Handbook. The course seems best suited for complete beginners or struggling sellers who need hand-holding through the process.
Beginner (No Prior Experience Needed)
light Light (1–5 Hours/Week)
Self-Paced (Work On Your Own Schedule)
Make Money
The general consensus leans positive, particularly among beginners who appreciate Nancy's clear teaching style and organized approach. However, experienced sellers express mixed feelings about the value proposition, especially given the strict no-refund policy that we'll discuss later.
"Nancy made everything so simple, opened my shop in a weekend!" - EtsyMasteryStudent
"Lots of practical examples, and she actually responds to emails." - CraftyEntrepreneur
"Was hoping for more advanced strategies, but it's perfect for beginners." - S.Hoffman
"A bit pricey, but saved me weeks of frustration, worth it for me." - JSmith_creates
"Much of this info is free on YouTube, but Nancy made it easy to follow in order." - MCarter
On Reddit's r/EtsySellers, we found Nancy mentioned positively for her free YouTube content, with one user stating, "I haven't taken her course, but I do like her YouTube videos. She gives a lot of good free information so I can imagine her course is good." However, skepticism about paid Etsy courses runs high, with many Redditors believing the information should be free.
Students generally find value in the structured approach and Nancy's teaching style, though the course's worth depends heavily on your existing Etsy knowledge and willingness to research free alternatives.
Nancy claims her course is "The Proven System To Launch, Market And Scale A Wildly Profitable Etsy Shop." The "proven system" part checks out, we found the curriculum well-structured. However, "wildly profitable" remains subjective and unverifiable. Nancy shares her $21K first-year results but wisely avoids guaranteeing specific income levels for students.
Currently $297 with payment plan option. We couldn't find evidence of significant price fluctuations or deep discount patterns.
The main upsell is private coaching (price undisclosed). We didn't find complaints about aggressive in-course upselling, which is refreshing.
Testimonials mention "going from no sales to consistent sales" and "finally understanding SEO." However, we couldn't find independently verified case studies or income reports from students achieving the "wildly profitable" results mentioned in marketing.
Marketing claims lean optimistic but avoid crossing into deceptive territory. The lack of specific income promises and focus on teaching systems rather than guaranteeing outcomes shows reasonable restraint.
Hosted on Teachable, a reliable and user-friendly platform we've seen work well for similar courses
Lifetime access to all materials including future updates, video streaming only (no downloads), downloadable PDFs and templates included
Fully responsive on Teachable's mobile app, though we recommend desktop for implementing strategies
Standard internet connection, modern browser, no specialized software needed
The technical delivery meets expectations for a $297 course. Teachable provides a smooth learning experience, and lifetime access with updates adds significant value. The inability to download videos might frustrate some learners, but it's standard practice for protecting intellectual property.
The most significant issue we encountered repeatedly is the strict no-refund policy. Multiple Trustpilot reviews express frustration, with one February 2023 review calling the content "extremely basic" and labeling the no-refund policy "a scam." Another October 2022 review stated: "Content is EXACTLY what you can find online for free... Absolutely no refunds."
Yes, this is a major concern. The website clearly states: "Due to the digital nature of our products... we have a NO REFUND POLICY." For a $297 course, this represents significant risk for buyers.
The sales page uses aspirational language ("wildly profitable Etsy shop") but stops short of making specific income promises. We appreciate that Nancy shares her own results ($21K first year) without guaranteeing similar outcomes for students.
Access to the private Facebook group is included, though external feedback about the community itself remains limited. We couldn't find reports of aggressive upselling within the course.
The no-refund policy stands out as the primary concern. While transparent, it's unusually strict for a mid-ticket digital product and leaves dissatisfied customers without recourse.
At $297, this course sits in the mid-ticket range. For complete beginners, the structured approach and time saved could justify the investment. However, motivated self-learners might achieve similar results with free resources and Etsy's Seller Handbook. The strict no-refund policy significantly impacts the value proposition, essentially making this a $297 gamble on whether the teaching style suits you.
After thorough analysis, we found Nancy Badillo's Etsy Mastery Course to be a legitimate, well-structured program that delivers on its basic promise of teaching Etsy fundamentals. Nancy's experience shines through in her practical approach, and the course content covers essential topics comprehensively.
However, we can't ignore the elephant in the room, the no-refund policy creates unnecessary risk for students. Combined with reports of some outdated content and the availability of similar information for free, we recommend approaching with caution.
If you're a complete beginner who values structured learning and can afford to risk $297, this course might accelerate your Etsy journey. But if you're comfortable with self-directed learning or already have basic Etsy knowledge, you'd likely find better value elsewhere. The 7.3/10 legitimacy score reflects solid content hampered by inflexible policies and questionable value for experienced sellers.
At $297, this course sits in the mid-ticket range. For complete beginners, the structured approach and time saved could justify the investment. However, motivated self-learners might achieve similar results with free resources and Etsy's Seller Handbook. The strict no-refund policy significantly impacts the value proposition, essentially making this a $297 gamble on whether the teaching style suits you.
No reviews yet for this course. Be the first to leave a review!
We spent considerable time analyzing Nancy Badillo's Etsy Mastery Course, and here's what we discovered. This self-paced program promises to guide sel...
We spent considerable time analyzing Nancy Badillo's Etsy Mastery Course, and here's what we discovered. This self-paced program promises to guide sel...
We spent considerable time analyzing Nancy Badillo's Etsy Mastery Course, and here's what we discovered. This self-paced program promises to guide sel...
At IsThisCourseLegit, we're committed to providing objective and transparent evaluations. Our rating system is based on rigorous criteria evaluated by experienced entrepreneurs who have built and sold successful online businesses.
Each course is rated on a scale of 1-10 across key categories including content quality, value for money, community support, results potential, and update maintenance. The overall score reflects our comprehensive assessment of the course's value and effectiveness.
For each review, we analyze all available online data to assess the course thoroughly. Our evaluation considers the quality of the content, the instructor's background, the marketing strategy, public perception, and authentic reviews from actual members, giving you a complete and balanced perspective.
If you're the creator of a course we've reviewed and believe there are any inaccuracies or outdated information in our review, we want to hear from you.
We implement strategies from the courses to validate their effectiveness.
We track course updates and community development over time.
Copyright © 2025 Is This Course Legit. All Rights Reserved